Music selection for new hymnal shaped by new table of contents

March 1, 2018

Music selection for new hymnal shaped by new table of contents

UNION, Mich. — The work of the Mennonite Worship and Song Committee is slow and joyful and involves a lot of singing.

Six members of the Resonate team sample past selections from Sing the Story as they choose songs for the new Mennonite collection to be published in 2020. The team met in February at Camp Friedenswald in Michigan. From left to right: Tom Harder, SaeJin Lee, Cynthia Neufeld Smith, Darryl Neustaedter Barg, Allan Rudy Froese, and project director Bradley Kauffman.

The 14-person committee, working as the “Resonate Team,” gathered at Camp Friedenswald in February to continue its work toward the 2020 release of a new hymnal for Mennonite Church Canada and Mennonite Church USA.

“We’re in an exciting season right now,” said Bradley Kauffman, project director. “In 2017, we received more than 2,100 submissions of new and original content ranging from visual art to written worship resources to songs and hymns. It’s energizing to work with that content.”

The committee sang and processed more than two hundred songs at its February gathering, a year after it started the selection process at another meeting. The group continues to discern what strikes a chord among committee members and what will resound with the larger church.

“We’ve been listening to Anabaptists across the United States and Canada to see what resonates with congregations in both countries,” Kauffman said.

At this recent meeting the committee affirmed a table of contents that has been underway for many months. The committee views the table of contents as a lens to evaluate both the canon of existing content and new submissions, and will use it to populate the sections of what will become the new hymnal to be published by MennoMedia.

Committee member Sarah Kathleen Johnson said the table of contents will help churches go one step deeper into the tradition of Hymnal: A Worship Book and how it shaped worship. “The table of contents of Hymnal: A Worship Book is quite unique in that it follows the flow of worship,” she said. “Thinking about that flow of worship helps shape decisions about what to include in the new book and how songs support the actions within worship.”

The committee has had holy moments as it’s gathered in a circle and sung and discussed music. The group is immensely grateful for the submissions and interest, as well as prayers. “As we carry out this work, we invite your prayers to accompany us as we select worship materials for MC Canada and MC USA,” Kauffman said.

Fundraising for the project continues, and MennoMedia hopes to raise another $200,000 to $300,000 this year. “As a small, nonprofit organization, we do not have the resources to create this massive project without the contributions of generous donors—individuals and congregations who are willing to be patrons and keep the final costs to congregations lower,” said Amy Gingerich, executive director and publisher for MennoMedia. “We continue to welcome donations for this project.”

“Resonate” has been a working name for the committee and its work, but an official name and logo for the suite of hymnal products will be announced soon, said Gingerich.

For more information or to schedule an interview, contact LeAnn Hamby at 540-908-3941 or email

To keep up with the latest news from the Resonate Team follow on Facebook


Learning How to Rock with Black Mennonite Women

We—Shine Project Director Rose Stutzman, Shine Curriculum Editor Chrissie Walls, and Shine Managing Editor Rachel Nussbaum Eby—had the privilege of attending Central District Conference’s annual women’s conference entitled “Black Mennonite Women Rock!” Women across Mennonite Church USA were invited to come to Camp Friedenswald, September 12–14.

RetreatImage We wanted to go because it was an opportunity to learn from black women and celebrate our common humanity. The gift of this particular retreat was that it was planned and led by black women.

We danced together Friday evening.

Dancing(Photo from Camp Friedenswald Facebook page. Chrissie is second from the left.)

Dancing2 (Photo from Camp Friedenswald Facebook page. Rose is third from the left.)

We worked on a block for the identity quilt.


(Photo from Camp Friedenswald Facebook page.)


We worshiped together, with singing led by Dr. Crystal Y. Sellers Battle, assistant professor of music at Bluffton (Ohio) University. (Photo by Rachel Nussbaum Eby.)

We listened to some incredible speakers:


Hyacinth Stevens, keynote speaker and co-pastor of King of Glory Tabernacle in the Bronx, New York (Photo from Camp Friedenswald Facebook page.)


Nekeisha Alexis-Baker, graphic designer and website specialist at Anabaptist Mennonite Biblical Seminary (Photo from Camp Friedenswald Facebook page.)


Sarah Thompson, executive director of Christian Peacemaker Teams (Photo from Camp Friedenswald Facebook page.)

CyneathaMillsapsCyneatha Millsaps, pastor at Community Mennonite Church in Markham, Illinois (Photo from Camp Friedenswald Facebook page.)

We came to find out what we weren’t aware of before.

Someone asked me (Rose) “Did you hear anything new? Learn anything new?” My answer was that knowing something on an intellectual level is very different from letting the stories and experiences of black women wash over you.  I have been committed to anti-racism, but this weekend—filled with fun, worship, and stories—took that intellectual assent to a new level. The stories, voices, and gifts of these particular, beautiful women will stay in my heart.

ThemeQuiltQuilt made by Hively Avenue Mennonite Church in Elkhart, Indiana, and Community Mennonite Church in Markham, Illinois, showing the history of African-Americans in the U.S. (Photo by Chrissie Walls.)

This retreat will impact our work as a Shine curriculum team. It deepened our commitment to sensitivity across color lines. When we write, we want to do so with care and humility knowing that each person’s life and story is a sacred trust. When we choose art and photos, we will be even more diligent in making a curriculum where all children can see themselves.

Images and language form children at a very young age. In Dark Girls, the documentary we watched during the retreat, we noticed just how early this can happen and were impressed with the importance of careful communication. We hope that Shine can be sensitive to the nuances of images and language. We want children of the next generation to know that all people are beloved children of God.

I (Rachel) knew that the color black often has negative connotations. The weekend made me even more aware of the pervasiveness of this idea, and together, Shine staff discussed ways to be more aware. We will handle the metaphor of light and darkness with even greater care. Dusk and evening can be a cool and comforting time. And darkness can be like a blanket, covering us and giving us rest.

I (Chrissie) witnessed openness to the movement of the Spirit. Women who came prepared to lead songs and share a particular message were able to remain open to God’s spirit moving in that particular time and situation. In curriculum we write a plan for Sunday school. We ask for God’s guidance when doing that. But we want people using the curriculum to be open to the Spirit as they use the curriculum in a particular time and space.

How have you been open to the Spirit when teaching Sunday school?

Rose, Rachel, and Chrissie
Shine curriculum staff